Siemens’ Tips for Panel Builders Series – Part 6: Determining the Overall SCCR of an Industrial Control Panel for UL

PBUS Siemens logo 400

November 3, 2020

Machines, their control panels, and other types of electrical equipment must be designed and sized in accordance with their location of installation. This ensures protection against the damaging effects of a short-circuit in the electrical equipment. 

In the US there is a legal requirement to determine the short-circuit current rating (SCCR) of an industrial control panel.

 

Did you know it is the responsibility of the user to calculate and determine the maximum available short-circuit current at the connection point (point of incoming supply)?

Unless otherwise agreed, a short-circuit at the incoming supply terminal is the responsibility of the user. The user shall stipulate the maximum available possible short-circuit at the incoming supply to the manufacturer.

Control panels are individually designed for specific applications

Short-circuit-based configuration of the industrial control panel shall be performed by the manufacturer. The industrial control panel shall be designed so that it supports the specified SCCR. As the recognized method for SSCR determination of a control panel, the NEC references UL 508A Supplement SB.

 

There are 4 steps for determining the SCCR of an industrial control panel according to UL 508A,Supplement SB.

 

Tips for you!

Determination of the SCCRs of built-in components Siemens6 1

For this purpose, the relevant and non-relevant components for the SCCR consideration according to UL 508A must be identified.

In accordance with Supplement SB4.2, apart from certain exceptions, all components in the power circuit shall be considered when determining the SCCR and shall express an SCCR in amperes or kiloamperes with specification of the voltage.

The overall SCCR for the control panel is determined by the weakest SCCR value of the components.

a.    Device markings or data sheets

The determination of the SCCR for all components is based either on device markings or component data sheets supplied by the manufacturer of the components.

b.   UL 508A, Table SB4.1, for components without SCCR marking

If no information is at hand, Table SB4.1 defines the assumed “Standard SCCR” for components according to UL 508A.

c.    If required – increase the SCCR through use of tested combinations

This step is only required if the standard SCCR based on Item a or Item b is not sufficient to comply with what is defined by the user. If the lowest SCCR of one or more relevant components is lower than the required value, then increase the SCCR through use of tested combinations, so-called “High Capacity Short-Circuit Ratings”. This can be found in the “UL Certificate of Compliance” (CoC).

 

If required — increase the overall SCCR of the control panel by using current limiting devices in the feeder circuit. Siemens6 2

In accordance with UL 508A, Supplement SB4.3, the maximum possible short-circuit current for components of the power circuit can be reduced by using current-limiting devices in the feeder circuit. It is imperative here, however, that the current-limiting devices are situated entirely within the feeder circuit.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Determing the overall SCCR of the control panel as specified in SB4.4. Siemens6 3

Determine the overall SCCR for the industrial control panel after the required measures have been established.

The overall SCCR for the control panel is determined by the weakest SCCR value of the component after the required and selected measures have been applied. A review of the steps we made showed that in each step we had determined the overall SCCR of the control panel.

 

 

 

 

 

 Simplfy the determination of the different scenarios in which the SCCR of separate components is increased. 

Siemens6 4

Use high SCCR values of tested combinations!

Instead of thinking about how to limit the current or which device can be used, or even thinking about paying more for a device with higher “Standard SCCR”, we recommend to use tested combinations.

When you use the “Standard SCCR” values of individual components, especially motor controllers and overload protection devices, you may end up with an industrial control panel that can only hold up to 5kA, 10kA, or even 15kA. The issue with these low values is that often industrial control panels will need to have an overall SCCR higher than any of these values.

The Siemens portfolio has been tested in accordance with the performance requirements, including short circuit requirements, and this includes the high fault current combination test. You will find also type 1 and type 2 test combinations on the certifications (CoC=Certificate of compliance).

Our TIA Selection Tool tool can be used to select the UL test combinations with a small amount of input. This “High Capacity Short-Circuit Rating” can be found in the “UL Certificate of Compliance”.

With the use of the CoC we can increase the critical product’s SSCR through use of tested combinations, or “High Capacity Short-Circuit Ratings”.

 

You will find more information on these links

Sizing and protection of control circuits according to UL

Type “1” and Type “2“ Coordination for contactors and motor starters acc. to UL 60947-4-1

TIA Selection Tool

 

Click here for more information.

Related Articles

Network Infrastructure Featured Product Spotlight

PBUS 14 Panduit logo 400

This webinar presented by Beth Lessard and Keith Cordero will be highlighting three Panduit solutions that will optimize network equipment and cabling to ensure that your spaces are efficiently and properly managed to support ever-evolving business needs of today and beyond. Products that will be featured include PanZone TrueEdge Wall Mount Enclsoure, Cable Managers, and Adjustable Depth 4-Post Rack.

REGISTER HERE


Editor’s Pick: Featured Product News

Siemens: SIMOVAC Non-Arc-Resistant and SIMOVAC-AR Arc-Resistant Motor Controllers

The Siemens SIMOVAC medium-voltage non-arc-resistant and SIMOVAC-AR arc-resistant controllers have a modular design incorporating up to two 12SVC400 (400 A) controllers, housed in a freestanding sheet steel enclosure. Each controller is UL 347 class E2, equipped with three current-limiting fuses, a non-load-break isolating switch, and a fixed-mounted vacuum contactor (plug-in type optional for 12SVC400). The enclosure is designed for front access, allowing the equipment to be located with the rear of the equipment close to a non-combustible wall.

Read More


Sponsored Content
Electrify Your Enterprise

Power is vital to production, and well-designed control cabinets are key. Allied Electronics & Automation offers a comprehensive collection of control cabinet solutions including PLCs, HMIs, contactors, miniature circuit breakers, terminal block connectors, DIN-rail power supplies, pushbutton switches, motor starters, overloads, power relays, industrial Ethernet switches and AC drives engineered to keep your operations running safely, reliably and efficiently.

Learn more HERE.


Products for Panel Builders

  • Panduit: G6 PDU Series Boosts Panduit PDU Offerings

    Panduit: G6 PDU Series Boosts Panduit PDU Offerings

    Panduit is pleased to announce the global release of its G6 PDU Series. The innovative G6 line marries the best-in-class form factor of the G5 Series with an upgraded intelligence card to bring faster performance along with new functions and cybersecurity improvements to customers. Among the main features of the G6 PDU is its low-profile… Read More…

  • Russelectric, A Siemens Business: ATS Remote Annunciator

    Russelectric, A Siemens Business: ATS Remote Annunciator

    Russelectric, A Siemens Business, introduces its new ATS Remote Annunciator (RTS-RA), a powerful accessory that brings together data from multiple Automatic Transfer Switches into a single display. The remote annunciator is designed to be configured by the customer. It allows monitoring of the position and status of up to eight Russelectric ATS types RTSCD and… Read More…